Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chris's avatar

You must have balls of steel Loan. Excellent article again.

Expand full comment
Peter's avatar

The parallels with Colombia during Alvaro Uribe's tenure are palpaple. Many congratulate Uribe for bringing down crime and turning Colombia from a no-go area to a thriving new focus for adventurous tourists. His policies did have significant popular support and did reduce crime somewhat (though this was exaggerated on both counts, in my view). But moreover, it came at a terrible cost that was borne by the most disadvantaged and marginalized sectors of the population. These sectors are naturally the least politically powerful, least able to get their voices heard in the public square, and least represented politically. Human rights violations during Uribe's time in office were horrendous and widespread. The false positives scandal is one of the more well-known and well-publicized examples, but is really just the tip of the iceberg. I think the experience of Colombia under Uribe shows how in the long-run these mano dura policies ultimately fail because they create a new set of problems of their own. Ireland also provides an interesting parallel: Internment in the northeast of Ireland in 1971, for example, may well have brought down violence that year, but the following year was the bloodiest of the entire period of the Troubles. I fear that something similar might happen here in the aftermath of this crackdown, though of course I hope not.

I think a better solution for both Colombia and El Salvador would have been some kind of peace and reconciliation process with transitional justice including some amnesty, social programs to alleviate the root causes of the maras, and a forum for both maras and victims to have their experiences heard and better understood by the wider populous. Something similar happened in Colombia with the FARC (though this has had its set of failures) and I see no reason why it couldn't be tried with less politically-motivated groups such as the Maras. AMLO and even Vicente Fox have suggested something similar in Mexico with the Cartels though I don't think AMLO really followed through with this once in office.

Also, I think we need to be skeptical of some of these polls showing such high support. 90% seems very high given that presumably many people have had family members who are involved with the Maras, and indeed many presumably have family members who have been wrongly caught up in all this. In a poor and highly unequal country like El Salvador, it wouldn't surprise me if the more well-off and more right-leaning sectors of the population are overrepresented in these polls. And I would be also be interested to hear who it is what organizations are conducting them and whether they have vested interest, political bias, et cetera.

Anyway, thanks for an interesting and informative read,

Peter Bolton

peterboltonjournalist.com

Expand full comment
53 more comments...

No posts